Customer Reviews

Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.

  • BW

    “These guy’s and gal’s are the best in the business.

  • B

    “It was very pleasant to speak with both agents on my last interaction. I spoke with Kara Fields when I initially called for pricing and Rosa Bennett when I called back to actually modify my policy. Both ladies were very pleasant and it was quite a different experience (in a very positive way) than a few previous times I’ve called in previous years. If you continue to have that high quality level of interaction and representation, I will have no reason to change agents for years to come.

  • MF

    “I recently checked rates thru our credit union (Liberty and Travelers) and Allstate, mostly in response to repeated mail offers. Seems you found us a pretty good insurance company. They couldn’t compete with Erie. Allstate wasn’t close. Liberty and Travelers were close on auto but they were to call back after checking rates with a home policy included. They didn’t call back. I assume they couldn’t compete and failing to call back was very unprofessional.”

  • RS

    “I have been with the company for almost 15 yrs which is a testament to their excellent service”

  • MR

    “Friendly, helpful, and quick. Great bunch of people”

  • TK

    “Excellent knowledge to ANY questions I have. Very pleased with Matt who helped me with my policy. Thank you so much.”

  • CV

    “I have had insurance with your company for many years. You have always been more than helpful in all my needs. To building a house and insurance for the materials to purchasing a new vehicle, atv, utv, trailers, camper, and my home. We have had a few fender benders and your staff has always been more than helpful. Thank you!!! ”

  • BC

    “Mitchell Insurance has met our business insurance needs for 6 years. The customer service is outstanding and are extremely happy to help with whatever we need. ”

  • DH

    “I enjoy the closeness of the relationship between me and my insurance agency. It means a lot to me to be able to call or text or even stop by and when I walk in the door they know who I am. That is what I get with this insurance agency. The prices are very competitive.”

  • MB

    “Our agent is super. Always has answers and helpful choices. ”

  • BB

    “Mitchell Agency and Laura Hadocy have always been available and responsive when we have had any issues or questions. And always worked to get us the appropriate coverage at the best possible price.”

  • AR

    “Matt G. is great! Very personable, prompt and well informed. ”

  • DR

    “Been with Mitchell Insurance for almost 10 years now for general liability insurance. They are always very helpful and responsive to whatever needs I have. I would recommend them to any small business owner. It always feels like they are on my team and genuinely want to be helpful. Certificate requests are always turned around same day, surety bonds as well. No complaints at all.

  • TC

    “The Agency will do an annual audit of your policies to insure you are getting the most competitive rates from a variety of insurers.
    Staff is alway courteous and helpful.”

  • DC

    “You guys always take care of my questions when I call in a polite and professional manor. ”