As our client, you will have a team of highly qualified professionals working for you to provide you with the best coverage for you, your family, or your business. Building a long-lasting relationship with our clients is our number one priority.
Amy Jenkins, CISR, CPIA
Amy Jenkins received her Property & Casualty insurance license in 1997 and her Life & Health insurance license in 2007. She specializes in personal and commercial lines of insurance. In 2004, she was awarded the Certified Insurance Service Representative designation. Amy is dedicated to educating her clients and providing an uncompromising level of customer service. She is a lifelong resident of Grove City, OH. Amy spends her free time traveling and vacationing on the many beaches in South Carolina and loves outdoor activities.
Brenda Metzger has worked in the insurance field for over 30 years. She is a licensed Property & Casualty and Life & Health agent who specializes in commercial insurance. Brenda is a lifelong resident of Baltimore, OH and has been married to her husband Jeff for more than 30 years. They have two children, Michael & Sarah. In her spare time, Brenda enjoys spending time with her grandchildren.
Bridgett started in the insurance industry in 2003 as a billing specialist in Fredericksburg, VA. She obtained her Property & Casualty license in 2004. She is from the hills of Eastern Kentucky and currently resides in Florence, KY with her son. She enjoys watching her son in all his activities, lake life with her family and is a fan of all University of Kentucky sports as well as the Miami Dolphins.
Chris Carr has worked in the insurance field for over 15 years. He received his Property and Casualty license in 2004 and specializes in personal lines. He is joining his wife, Chrissy Carr, at Mitchell Insurance. They have 3 children and 2 grandchildren. He enjoys golf and other outdoor activities with his family and friends.
Chrissy Carr has been a licensed Property, Casualty and Life Insurance agent for over 20 years. Chrissy’s philosophy is to treat her clients as she would want to be treated, making sure she is protecting them against unforeseen circumstances. She resides in Florence with her husband Chris and has 2 children and 2 grandchildren. Chrissy says “Life can get crazy and things happen. My goal is to make sure when the crazy happens my clients are protected so they know I have their back! As a mother of a police officer I get it, the unforeseen can be scary. I want to take part of the worry off their shoulders.”
Christine has worked in customer service for over 20 years. She resides in Marysville, Ohio with her husband of 20 years, Michael, their daughter, Emma and 3 cats and 3 dogs. Christine enjoys reading, gardening, crafting and spending time with her family.
Colin Mitchell began working for Mitchell Insurance in 2015. He graduated from the University of Cincinnati in 2018 with a bachelor’s degree in Business Entrepreneurship. When he is not working, Colin enjoys volunteering at The Miracle League, a baseball league for kids with disabilities, as well as watching television and playing all kinds of sports
Corey Mitchell began working for Mitchell Insurance in 2016. Corey received his Property & Casualty license in 2016, and his Life & Health License in 2018. Prior to working for the agency, he attended the University of Dayton, graduating with a BA in Criminal Justice and a minor in Cyber Security Management. Corey is a Bocce Ball, Basketball Skills, and Softball Skills coach with Hilliard Bobcats Special Olympics. When he’s not working, Corey enjoys volunteering at Miracle League, watching Netflix, eating pizza, and staying active.
Courtney Cipparrone, CISR, CPIA
Branch Manager, Lancaster
Courtney Cipparrone received her Property & Casualty and Life Insurance licenses in 2012. She graduated from Ohio University and majored in Business Applied Management. She currently resides in Lancaster with her husband Bill, son Hudson and daughter Hayden. She loves to travel, enjoys boating, snowboarding and spending time with her family and friends.
Deb Selvaggio started in the insurance industry in 2001. She obtained her Property and Casualty License in 2003. In 2011, she was awarded the Certified Insurance Service Representative designation. Deb resides in Pickerington, Ohio with her husband of 36 years, Mark. They have two daughters, Amy and Laura, and a granddaughter, Emma. In her spare time, Deb enjoys spending time with her granddaughter, reading mystery novels, going to movies and concerts.
Jacki Maynard received her insurance license in 1981. She enjoys getting to know each one of her clients and loves to work with them all individually. Jacki has 4 children and a blended family of 13 grandchildren ranging in age from 6 to 24 as well as her first great grandchild born this year. She is very proud to say that her grandson will be wrestling for the Ohio State Buckeyes this year.
Jared has been a licensed Property & Casualty and Life & Health agent since 2007 where he specializes in personal & commercial lines and the life insurance needs of his clients. Jared is a graduate of The Ohio State University where he received his Bachelors of Science degree in Turf-grass Science. Outside the office you will likely find him on the links, watching OSU games and spending time with family and friends.
Jason Barlow is a Property & Casualty and Life & Health Insurance Agent with more than eight years’ experience in the insurance industry. He is a graduate of The Ohio State University with a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration. Jason currently resides in Powell with his wife Andrea and their three children, Paige, Evan, and Addison. In his spare time, Jason enjoys watching/coaching his kids’ sports, cheering on the Ohio State Buckeyes, Chicago Cubs, and Chicago Bears, as well as volunteering with the Make-A-Wish Foundation.
Jenah Wandell has worked in insurance for over 7 years. She received her Property & Casualty license in 2012 and obtained her Life license in 2018. Jenah grew up in Plainwell, Michigan and graduated with a degree in psychology from Bowling Green State University. Jenah currently resides in Columbus with her two dogs, Rickon and Sansa. In her spare time, Jenah enjoys going to the local vintage toy shows, kayaking, and spending time with friends and family.
Kamron Sweeney received her insurance license in 2016. She is licensed in Property & Casualty and Life & Health Insurance. Kamron resides in Somerset with her husband Shea, their daughter Murphie and her 2 dogs, Roxy and Griffin. She enjoys fishing, sewing and spending time with family and friends.
Keeley Leising received her property and casualty license in 2020. Keeley graduated from Winthrop University in 2020 where she got her degree in Exercise Science and played four years of Division I soccer. In her free time, she enjoys, playing, coaching, and watching soccer, as well as hiking, cooking, and traveling.
Branch Manager, Plain City
Kelly Ray has worked in the insurance industry for more than 10 years. She received her property & casualty and life & health insurance licenses in 2006. Her focus is to help secure insurance products that will protect clients in the event of an unfortunate incident. Outside of work she enjoys spending time with her 3 boys and friends.
Kevin Miller is a licensed Life & Health and Property & Casualty agent who specializes in Life & Health insurance. He resides in Galloway with his wife Tish. He has two sons and enjoys spending time with his four grandchildren. Kevin is a dedicated member of The Knights of Columbus where he serves as a State Officer, and continues to help his church, family and community.
Lisa Corbett has 20 years of experience working in the insurance field. She started in auto claims and then received her Property and Casualty license in 2007. She and her husband Joe are lifelong residents of the Columbus area. They are supporters of the American Legion and VFW where her husband is a member of both. She is a parishioner of Saint Cecilia Church and serves as a chairperson on the festival committee and as a bingo volunteer. She enjoys baking, and spending time with family.
Markus Mueller, CPIA
Markus Mueller has been in the insurance industry since 2003. His past experience is in Life & Health and Voluntary Benefits for small and midsize employers, and he received his Property & Casualty insurance license in 2009. He is active with local chambers of commerce and supports various charity organizations. Markus and his wife, Teej, live here in the Treasure Coast area with their dog Google. Their adult children live in 3 different states across the country.
Michelle Allen has worked in the insurance industry for 30 years and received her Property/Casualty license in 1997. Michelle resides in Pataskala, Ohio with her husband, James and their son, Tyler. She enjoys spending time with her family and friends, vacationing in Myrtle Beach as well as fishing and boating on Lake Erie.
Mike Knoth has worked in the insurance field since graduating from Bowling Green State University in 1987. Mike began his career in commercial lines underwriting, became an agency marketing representative, and obtained his Property & Casualty license in 2008. Mike and his wife Tanya reside in Hilliard with their two children. In his spare time, he enjoys golf, coaching youth sports, and watching his kids play sports.
R. Matt Gardner, CIC, CPIA
Matt Gardner has been a licensed Property & Casualty and Life & Health agent since 2004, specializing in commercial / business lines of insurance. He earned his CPIA (Certified Professional Insurance Agent) designation in 2012, his CIC (Certified Insurance Counselor) designation in 2016, and was named Erie Insurance Producer of the Year for the state of Ohio in 2019. He attended The Ohio State University, majoring in Economics, and now resides in Worthington with his wife Kristi and his sons Evan and Cody. In his spare time, he enjoys golf, platform tennis, watching his boys play hockey, and vacationing with his family.
Rachel Billman received her property and casualty license in 2020. Rachel graduated from Wittenberg University in 2018 with a degree in Business Marketing. Prior to working for the agency, she was working in the reconstruction and restoration industry cultivating relationships and developing marketing materials. She is excited to bring that knowledge to Mitchell insurance. When Rachel is not working she enjoys spending time with her family and visiting the local coffee shops.
Robb Mitchell has worked in the insurance field since graduating from Bowling Green State University. Robb started as an adjuster with the Erie Insurance Group in Lima, and in 1993 started his own agency out of his home in Hilliard. Robb has grown Mitchell Insurance to one of Erie Insurance’s largest and best agencies in Ohio. Robb and his wife Sue reside in Dublin. They enjoy golf and boating, as well as working with and helping out with many local charity events.
Rosa Bennett is a licensed property and casualty agent who is committed to providing excellent customer service. Over the years, Rosa has lived over seas, in Texas, Washington and California. She returned to her native state of Ohio nearly ten years ago. She and her three children now reside in Hilliard. Rosa enjoys reading, cooking and spending time with her family and friends.
Ryan Anthony received his property and casualty license in 2021. Ryan has been in the insurance field for over 8 years. He resides in Westerville, Ohio with his wife Heather and son Rhett. When he is not in the office, Ryan enjoys spending time with family and friends, travelling, watching sports especially OSU football, and going to concerts.
Shawn Allman, LUTCF
Shawn Allman received his Property & Casualty and Life Insurance license in 2011 and achieved his LUTCF (Life Underwriting Training Council Fellow) designation in 2013, while previously working for Liberty Mutual Insurance Company. He attended The Ohio State University where he earned a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration. Shawn currently resides in Ashley, Ohio with his wife Megan, and two children, Alison and Hunter. Shawn enjoys cycling, hunting, golfing, coaching and spending time with family and friends.
Stephanie Lilly has been a licensed Property & Casualty insurance agent since 2013. She resides in Grove City with her daughter. Stephanie has two dogs, Junior and Google. In her spare time she enjoys camping, boating, kayaking, fishing, riding horses, hunting, and spending the weekends outdoors with her family and friends.
Taylor Brown grew up in Hilliard, OH and is attending Columbus State Community College. She obtained her property and casualty license in 2020. In her free time, she enjoys dancing, hiking, cooking, baking, and visiting her family. She has organized and participated in dance charity events for domestic violence shelters around Ohio.
Tim Ante started in the insurance industry in 2010 as a claims adjuster. He gained valuable knowledge about policies, coverage, and the claims process. In 2014 he obtained his Property & Casualty license and moved to the agency side of the business. He and his wife have two children, and reside in northern Kentucky. They enjoy keeping active and watching movies.
Tresia Bramblette has worked in the insurance industry since 2000 and received her Property & Casualty insurance license in 2002. She resides in Pleasantville, Ohio with her husband, Bill. She has a daughter & a son and enjoys spending time with her grandchildren and family. Tresia is dedicated to providing the best customer service for her clients’ insurance needs.