Skip to ContentSkip to Footer
(800) 773-8630
How can we help?
Florida File a Claim
Mitchell Insurance Logo
Get A
Quote
Write A
Review
YOU'RE UNIQUE
Your Insurance Solution Should Be Too.
diverse group of people smiling with thumbs up

Our Insurance Products

Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Business Insurance
Life Insurance

Mitchell Insurance Agency specializes in Auto, Business, Home, and Life Insurance.

Insuring Ohio & Nearby Communities — Coverage in 17 States

WHAT TYPE OF INSURANCE?
It’s easy to run down a checklist of the type of insurance we need to protect ourselves. Home insurance, car insurance, life insurance, business insurance, etc. However – when life takes an unexpected turn, will you have the right insurance, the right coverage to protect yourself and your family?

This is where Mitchell Insurance Agency excels as a specialist in insurance coverage and products. Your Mitchell Insurance Agency Agent can use this knowledge to guide you through options that are right for you and your individual situation.

Mitchell Insurance Agency Service Areas map
Erie Insurance has been providing the protection you need and the service you expect, all at a great price. See why more than 90% of customers stay with Erie Insurance year after year.
Get an Auto Quote
Get an Auto Quote
Pay Your Bill
Pay Your Bill
Life Insurance Calculator
Life Insurance Calculator
Access Online Account
Access Online Account

ERIE's Your Turn® Program

There is a new way Erie Insurance is looking out for you and wants to help you stay safe on the road.
learn more

Recent News & Updates

Young co-workers collaborating in office.
How to Measure & Use Employee Satisfaction Metrics
April 28, 2025
Employee satisfaction is a key indicator of how well an organization performs in terms of its work environment, leadership, and support. By measuring satisfaction regularly,…
Young female doctor high-fiving child patient.
Understanding Health Insurance Networks
April 25, 2025
Navigating health insurance networks can be tricky but understanding the terms “in-network” and “out-of-network” is key to managing your healthcare costs. Reviewing what these terms…
Couple looking at life insurance options.
Options to Consider When Your Term Life Insurance Expires
April 22, 2025
Life insurance provides invaluable protection for your loved ones, but what happens when your term life insurance policy reaches the end of its coverage period?…
Tim Gannon
5/5
Best insurance company I have ever had to deal with!
Tim G.
SM
5/5
I have been a customer for about 15 years and have always received prompt and...
Shirley M.
DD
4/5
We have been with Mitchell Insurance since 1990 - recommended to us when we...
Dan D.
DANA BROWN
5/5
*** EXCELLENT CUSTOMER SERVICE INSURANCE COMPANY! *** Matt Gardner always...
DANA B.
Jeff Royer
5/5
Great customer service very friendly they insure my home and trucks they are...
Jeff R.
JR
5/5
Michael Pinardi was very professional and explained all options clearly and...
Jennifer R.
See All Reviews
American Modern Insurance Logo
Dairyland Logo
Erie Insurance Logo
Foremost Insurance Logo
Hagerty Insurance Logo
Liberty Mutual Insurance Logo
Nationwide Insurance Logo
Progressive Insurance Logo
Safeco Insurance Logo
Security First Insurance Logo
Travelers Insurance Logo
Geico Logo
Beautiful people showing thumbs up, looking at camera and cheerfully smiling.

Contact Mitchell Insurance Agency

Let one of our experts customize a solution that’s right for you.

Talk To Us Today