Mitchell Insurance Agency - Insuring All of Ohio, Kentucky, and Florida, Including Plain City, Grove City, Lancaster, Florence, and Fort Pierce

Offering a wide range of options for Auto / Car Insurance, Home / Condo / Renters Insurance, Business / Commercial Insurance, and Life / Health Insurance

Awards2WHAT TYPE OF INSURANCE?
It’s easy to run down a checklist of the type of insurance we need to protect ourselves. Home insurance, car insurance, life insurance, business insurance, etc. However – when life takes an unexpected turn, will you have the right insurance, the right coverage to protect yourself and your family?

This is where Mitchell Insurance excels as specialists in insurance coverage and products. Your Mitchell Insurance Agent can use this knowledge to guide you through options right for you and your individual situation.

  • Joyce Lee Abram
    Great response and initial contacts for > 3 years.
  • Erin and Shawn Morgan
    Great customer service.
  • Christina Dillard
    Huge thanks to Courtney at Mitchell Insurance!
  • Mindy Wilkinson Crawford
    It's 100% service after the sale!
  • DANA BROWN
    EXCELLENT CUSTOMER SERVICE INSURANCE COMPANY!
 

Insurance Quotes

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • ALFA Insurance
  • American Strategic Insurance
  • CNA
  • Citizens Property Insurance
  • Dairyland Auto
  • Erie Insurance
  • Foremost Insurance
  • Grange Insurance Companies
  • Greater New York
  • Hagerty Insurance
  • KEMI Kentucky Employers' Mutual Insuranc
  • Liberty Mutual Insurance
  • MAPFRE / Commerce Insurance
  • MetLife Insurance
  • Nationwide Insurance
  • Ohio FAIR Plan
  • Pekin Insurance
  • Philadelphia Insurance
  • Progressive Insurance
  • Safeco Insurance
  • Security First Insurance
  • Travelers Insurance
  • United States Liability Insurance
  • Utica National Insurance
  • Victoria Insurance
  • Western Reserve Group

Recent News & Updates

Top Holiday Pet Safety Tips

The holidays are an exciting time of year full of get togethers, gifts and delicious food. While we’re focused on a season full of parties and fun times, a pet might think differently. Extra noise and visitors can leave pets feeling stressed. As we keep holiday and winter tips in mind for people, there are holiday and winter tips for our furry friends, too. Here’s... Read Article

Tips for Hosting Thanksgiving Dinner

The Thanksgiving holiday is the kick off to the United States’ holiday season. The holiday focuses on spending time with family and friends and, of course, having a delicious meal.  If you’re hosting the holiday gathering this year, here are a few tips to keep in mind and to hopefully make it an even more enjoyable holiday: Plan Ahead One of the first items on... Read Article

Prepping Your Kitchen for Thanksgiving Dinner

Before the guests arrive and the meal is served, here’s what you need to know about preparing your kitchen before your upcoming Thanksgiving and holiday meals. Appliances We use them throughout the year cooking and preparing meals, but it’s important to make sure your stove, oven, refrigerator and dishwasher are all in working order before the big day.    Use the self-cleaning function on your... Read Article

Understanding Auto Insurance-ERIE "Xtras"

Visible “Xtras” The next time you look over your auto policy, look for the “Xs” throughout the margins. These are all of the “Xtra Protection Features” that are automatically included with your ERIE auto policy. Clearly, it’s the little things that all add up to the bigger picture. Here are just a few of the things you’re covered for (and always have been). Road Trip.... Read Article

Specializing In Erie Insurance

Erie Insurance has been helping customers since 1925 with their auto, home, business, and life insurance needs.